I feel like I have no place as a non binary person. Mainstream spaces are full of tucutes, but 4tran adjacent spaces seem to get more and more weird like that. Am I still welcome here? Is my dysphoria enough or are we already actual anti-enby transmedicalists now?

This is the post btw: https://www.reddit.com/r/4tran4/comments/1sczen7/comment/oehh2ss/

  • Grandfather's Clock
    2·
    12 hours ago

    So like did you look at OP’s post snd the image attached to it or are you simply ignorant

    • Ray Blanchard
      1·
      12 hours ago

      what is the implication here, i feel like youre being intentionally vage.

      are you trying to imply the joke being made in the screenshot is the same thing as harassing someone for not being “truetrans” enough?

      • Grandfather's Clock
        2·
        12 hours ago

        I mean… yeah? I think it’s pretty reasonable to not want transsexual communities to be actively hostile to fellow transsexuals for transphobic (trutrans bullshit is just downstream of Blanchardism/Benjaminism) reasons

        • Ray Blanchard
          1·
          12 hours ago

          “fellow transsexuals”

          non binary isnt transsexual though. there is no third sex to trans into. non binary is a social identity. there are probably people who are transsexual and identify as non binary but theyre not the same.

          also 4tran adjacent spaces are literally the only spaces ive been able to find at least that arent overrun by nondysphoric (cis) people so while yeah i think “if you do xyz youre faketrans” is stupid, keeping out genuine actual fake trans people is reasonable.

          • Grandfather's Clock
            2·
            12 hours ago

            So, you understand that transsexuals can be non-binary, but you still don’t think hostility towards non-binary people in transsexual spaces is a problem?

            You can keep out cis people without resorting to nb hate

            • Ray Blanchard
              1·
              12 hours ago

              this isnt really even hostility though its pretty obviously a joke. i think making fun of the fact that non binary people’s identity is used to be transphobic towards transsexuals is fine. because that happens insanely often. the original post that comment was on was calling a (likely binary) trans woman non binary because she had big hands. 99% of the time “non binary” people are cis, and even when there’s nobody involved who identifies as non binary, that identity is commonly used against binary transsexuals. like in the original post on reddit.